Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Orion OmniVista 60ST Halley's Comet vintage scope review

So here I am with yet another 60mm vintage scope. I have gone through, lets see......Kasai 60ST orange tube 60mm (f/6), Yosco 60mm (f/11.7) metal tube dud, Celestron Cometron CO60 (f/11.7) plastic tube (probably made by Kasai of Japan as well as it is very similar to my Cometron CO40 (f/20) and the Kasai 60ST), Meade blue tube 60mm and now the Orion OmniVista 60ST. If you have been following my blog you would know by now that I have a soft spot for small scopes, especially 80's vintage ones. I can't really tell you why I have an affinity for these scopes. It might be due to the fact that I grew up with astronomy in the 80's and spent heaps of time looking at all those cool ads in the mags and not being able to afford even a measly 60mm scope. Talk about reliving your childhood and teen years!

"The Orion Halley's Comet Special: OmniVista 60 on vintage alt-az mount"

Now I trawl Astromart, the local Craigslist and even e Bay, and do occasionally come across gems for cheap. Most scope sellers are pretty savvy these days and vintage scope (especially complete outfits such as the 60's and 70's produced Unitron's, Sear's, JC Penney's (most of these either Towa's (Circle T), Vixen's (Circle V) and Park's can cost anywhere from $100 to $400 bucks a pop. Yup these "heirloom" quality 60mm long focal length (most come in at between 700 and 910mm focal lengths) are more expensive when they come complete in their wooden box holders, equatorial mounts (some even with clock drives) and a full complement of accessories (mostly 0.965" eyepieces, 2x barlow lenses and moon and sun (sic...these should never be used and should be smashed and thrown away ASAP). One dead giveaway to their 60's and 70's heritage is their metal focus knobs, something rarely seen these days in small 60, 70 and 80mm scopes.

Anyway to cut the story short, while browsing e Bay one lazy Saturday morning, I stumbled across a very familliar looking scope. Now where have I seen this cute lil short tube...oh yes in an ad in my 1985 Orion Telescopes catalog! This scope was released during the Halley's Comet fever era, and was sold on a flimsy looking tabletop tripod, but came with a spring loaded 6x30mm finder, 1.25" rack and pinion focuser and screw on prism diagonal. The scope also came with two 1.25" eyepieces, a 28mm and 15mm. Price back in the day was $229. The one I found did not come complete, the OTA that is. This set is partially complete as the previous owner mounted it on a vintage yoke mount that has slow motion controls in both altitude and azimuth (nice mount by the way). I will have to do a little research on when slow motion controls in azimuth was removed from these small scope mounts. My guess is sometime in the late 80's. The current crop of chinese and taiwanese made small yoke mounts do not have this option. All they have is slow motion controls in the altitude department.

"As the late Steve Irwin would say "Isn't she a beauty"

When released in the mid 80's, the scope did not have a name. I did a little more snooping around on the internet and found out that Orion had indeed given this sweet lil scope a name....Orion OmniVista. I can't find any ad's for this so I am not sure if it was sold as just an OTA or with the tabletop mount as back in 1985. Anyone out there with vintage Orion Catalog's e mail me if you have a copy of this ad!

The OTA itself is very solidly built, and I dare say more solidly built than most of its longer tube brethren. This 20" OTA weights in at a hefty 3.2lb, and this is the OTA alone. The metal retainer ring for the main objective, which only looks to be fully coated (blue reflections only) has the aperture and focal length inscribed onto it (aperture 60mm and focal length 420mm-f/7). The scope, in its native form, comes with a spring loaded, dovetail (non standard and does not accept the current dovetails from the chinese finderscopes....the dovetail is smaller and slips in from the front, with a lock knob down the front too) 6x30mm finder (which is absent in my sample, which comes with a holder that looks like it came from one of them Meade ETX's, but no finder). The focuser knobs are huge for a 60mm scope and are a very sturdy plastic. The rack and pinion focuser is very precise with no play when you rack it in and out of the focuser. It also comes with a focus lock, which will come in handy when you use it for wide field imaging.

"Looking down the barrel of the scope...the business end"

Looking down the business end, I do not see anything that would suggest that the main objective is stoppered down. There is nothing immediately behind the objective. Also looking through the focuser end of the OTA, I can see the objective in its entirety when racking the focuser in and out all the way, suggesting that there is no light cut off from the tube being too short, or the focuser being too long. One quirk of the OTA though is its diagonal. This OTA does not accept the standard 1.25" diagonals (even though it has a focuser in the 1.25" format). What is does have is a thread (not 1.25", appears a little smaller) for the prism star diagonal to screw on that comes with the OTA. I was bummed by this, but upon testing, the prism diagonal seems to work very well with the OTA.

"Aperture=60mm; Focal length=420mm, fully coated optics only"

In the Field




Preliminary inspections out of the way, now it was time to test the scope to see if it performs as well as a 60mm scope should. One problem I often encounter with refractors is miss collimation resulting in imperfect airy discs. A good refractor should have very tight airy disc and the expanding disc should look identical on both sides of the focus. Testing the scope on the stars, the OTA exhibited perfect airy discs and pinpoint stars at the focus point!

"I could get used to this...slo mo on azimuth....something only found on older mounts"

Since I did not have a working finder on the OTA as of yet, I eyeballed bright test objects. In two suburban testing sessions, I observed the 90% illuminated moon (about 1 days out from full moon) and a 4 days past opposition Mars in the evening sky; as well as Saturn and Venus in the predawn sky. I had trouble bagging deep sky objects from my light drenched skies, and the lack of a finder made things even more difficult. Will have to update this blog when I do get the scope under darker skies!

"Slo-mo altitude adjustment, the standard found on todays chinese alt-az mounts"

I used my 24.5mm Meade SWA eyepiece, working at 17x magnification as the finder eyepiece, my 20mm Orion Expanse, working at 21x and my TeleVue 6mm Radian, working at 70x, as my high powered planetary eyepiece. This lil beauty is definately a keeper. Planets were nice and sharp, as was the moon. I had superb, if warm yellow'ish views (typical of fast achromats) of Saturn and its rings, and though I could make out Cassini's division when the seeing steadied. Venus looked very good at 70x too (Seemed to be the best magnification for sharp color free views). I also pushed the magnification above the 60mm maximum limit of 50x per inch with my Orion Shorty Plus barlow to 140x, but CA became a problem and the views dimmed too much. I also used the scope for the total lunar eclipse (14th of April 2014) and even caught some quick looks at a rather featureless Mars at the same magnifications as above. The planetary disc was very sharp though.

"The focuser end showing the screw on metal thread for the prism diagonal"

The mount is of an older vintage as well. This is not a standard issue with this scope, but was a joy to use. There is still that annoying offshoot that one needs to figure in with the altitude adjustment, but I really liked the slow motion control in azimuth. First time using this function on such a small alt-az mount! The flimsy wooden legs are best fully collapsed or extended to about midway since it shakes too much when fully extended. It also comes with one of those triangular plate trays that attach to the mount with wing nuts. I find it easiest to leave one attached to the mount so I can collapse and carry the mount.

All in all I think I got a great bargain for $50 bucks. This scope seems to be a keeper, but only time will tell if I decide otherwise.....

Saturday, April 12, 2014

"Unleashing the the Imaging Monster" with a Meade DSI II OSC

Prologue

"NGC3242: Ghost of Jupiter Planetary in Hydra (top) and M97: The Owl Planetary in Ursa Major""

The long slumber is over. I tried to surpress it, but I can no longer hold it back. It started off as quick shots of the moon and the milky way with a standard bridge digital camera. This escalated into a dedicated deep sky imaging CCD camera. About a year ago I started on this quest, to take images of the our wonderful night sky. My first stop, naturally, was those modified webcams that could be used to take pics of the brighter members of our solar system with a non motorized mount. I figured I would ease my way into the realm of astrophotography. To that, I purchased a Orion Star Shoot Moon and Planetary Imager II. Did not know what I was getting into. Getting the camera to work with my existing scopes itself was a challenge. I quickly learned that one cannot simply attach a camera to the eyepiece of a non motorized telescope and get good images (or images for that matter as the scope needed sufficient back focus!!).


"M62: Black Eye Galaxy in Coma Berenices"

As fate would have it, I chanced upon a cheap Meade Deep Sky Imager I One Shot Color (DSI I OSC) camera on Astromart. That camera coaxed the imaging beast from within, one that was always there, simmering and waiting for a chance to be unleashed. Once a visual observer, I am now more of an astroimager (even though I still stay true to my visual roots and take an hour or two out of every dark sky session to drink in the faint starlight). As a result my observing habits changed. My most used scope went from my big 10" f/5 dob and Celestron/Vixen C6 to a 102mm GOTO Celestron NexStar. This small nifty scope enabled me to spend more time enjoying the views, while imaging or sketching. I also could hit more objects in a night than I previously could. Together with this scope, and camera, I spent countless of nights under Pinos and Malibu skies, imaging as I went along. I spent more than a year with my first DSI I OSC. It was a constant companion of mine, and it went with me everytime I went observing. I was amazed at what it could do, even with my limited equipment and knowledge. My problem was always its limited FOV and small images. The camera worked great. It was just inadequate for larger, sprawling objects. I did do some wide field imaging with a 70mm Celestron Travescope OTA mounted on my NexStar mount.


 

"M101 (top), M81 (middle), M82 (bottom) galaxies in Ursa Major"

Enter the Meade DSI II OSC 

"M105 group (top), M95 (middle) and NGC2903 (bottom) in Leo"

After some soul searching a decision was made to actively seek out a CCD with a bigger imaging chip that was within budget. Enter the Orion Star Shoot Deep Space Imager II, which had a bigger chip and TEC cooling. Found one for cheap on Astromart so I bit the bullet and purchased it. The camera got as far as my light polluted playground and a single trip to Malibu. The camera was heavier and bigger and used a different image capture software, the industry standard MaxIm DL.  But the camera and software proved to be not as user friendly as the Meade DSI I OSC and the Envisage software. I then put it back up on Astromart and the camera was sold in a flash. Back to the drawing board and my lil Meade DSI I OSC. Then fate came a knocking once again, I found my first camera's older brother, an upgrade, the Meade DSI II OSC with a larger CCD chip and a temperature sensor for dark frames. On testing, the camera performed as well as its little brother. It had the additional advantage (compared to the Orion SSDSIII) of being similar in size, weight and simplicity to the Meade DSI I OSC. I had found my ideal camera (for now)!!!!!!!

"Meade DSI's I (left) and II (right) OSC side by side"

Meade DSI II OSC specs:
Model / Part Number:
Deep Sky Imager II / 04526  

CCD Sensor:
High Sensitivity Color Sony EXview HAD CCDT Sensor (ICX429AKL)  

Chip Dimensions Pixels:
5.59mm (w) x 4.68mm (h); 8mm diagonal (type 1/2) 752 x 582 pixels (437,664 pixels)  

Pixel Size (in microns):
8.3 microns (w) x 8.6 microns (h)  

Temperature Sensor:
Built in temperature sensor measures degrees in celsius and matches it to each dark frame  

A/D Conversion :
16-bit (greater image depth and contrast)  

Min. - Max. Exposure Time:
1/10,000 of a second to one hour  

Housing:
Anodized die-cast aluminum  

USB Compatibility:
High Speed 2.0 and 1.1  

Size / Weight of product:
3.25" x 3.25" x 1.25"/ 10 oz. 


"M94 (Top): The Croc's Eye, M106 (middle) and M63: The Sunflower (bottom) Galaxies in Canes Venatici"

Three weekends on and I finally plucked up the courage to sell my old faithful. I rather it go to someone who would use it heaps, like I did when starting out with astrophotography. This is an awesome lil camera to start with as it greatly reduces the learning curve and can still generate some really pretty snapshots of the deep sky! My only regret with it was not playing around with different image formats. I did not push my lil camera to its limits!!!!!

"M83 galaxy in Hydra"

So after some initial testing from light polluted skies, and experimenting with different file formats (FITS vs TIFF vs BMP) with the Meade DSI II OSC, the imaging bug struck me even harder, much like Mjolnir! I spent the last two weekends imaging from my preferred site, Solstice Canyon park in Malibu.  Seeing how my usual blog goes, I will do a writeup after my dark sky session. I figured I do things a little different this time and write about my experience imaging with the Meade DSI II instead. In total I spent 7 hours imaging and visual observing.


"M84/86 and a portion of the Markarian's Chain in Virgo"

And we are off for some imaging at Malibu 27th March and 5th of April 2014 

"M53 Globular (top) and NGC4565 Galaxy in Coma Berenices"

I spent the eve of Cesar Chavez's day (27th of March) and last Saturday (5th of April) imaging from Solstice Canyon at Malibu. Conditions were rather nice. It was not windy at all, as it was all through Dec, Jan and Feb, and it did not get very cold until midnight hit. Also everything ran oh so smoothly. The mount was humming along just fine and dandy, hitting every object pretty much center or slightly to the left of the FOV on both nights. On most objects, I did not even need to put in the eyepiece to frame the object and then refocus. All I had to do is slew, hit the left or right buttons three to four times and whala...object acquired! The DSI II was also performing very well, as was the laptop. No stalling, no hanging and no frequent updates (the night prior to these two trips were just a weird night when nothing went right). The only small hiccup I encountered was losing some good frames on the 27th of March. I am not quite sure what happened, but that was one of the reasons why I went back this 1st quarter weekend to bag more objects. And I was there late as well since we had a dinner party to attend in Irvine.

M51: The Whirlpool Galaxy in Canes Venatici"

As far as the sessions went, I bagged all the objects I had on my list. Starting at Leo, I polished off NGC 2903 (although I wished I had the better frames, this was one of the objects that did not get saved properly). Then went on to do some old faves such as M81/M82/M97 in Ursa Major, M83 in Hydra, M3/M64 in Coma Berenices and M44/M67 in Cancer. All in all, I managed to go much deeper than with the DSI I. I think this is partly to do with the file formats since I was experimenting with FITS at 32 bit and TIFF at 16 bit. It was here that I learnt that somehow the color balance gets skewered when I save stuff in the FITS format (and combine all four channels, luminence, red, green and blue in MaxIm DL....this is very evident with my M82, M97, M64 and M83 shots pictured in this blog update). Weird? You tell me. Another revelation was that the DSI II had less amp glow than the original DSI I, so I could coax more detail out of the darkness of the frame.

"M12 (top) and M10 (bottom) globulars in Ophiuchus"

When the laptop battery finally died (usually last about 2 hours or more) I went to visual with the Astroscan and the 102GT. The Astroscan is just so easy to use, even easier than the SkyScanner. My fave eyepiece in this one is the 13T6 Nagler. Spent a good amount of observing time looking at all the galaxies (the Leo galaxies M65/M66; M95/M96/M105, Virgo's Markarian chain of galaxies, Coma's galaxies M64, The Blackeye Galaxy; NGC4565, Canes Venatici galaxies M51, The Whirlpool Galaxy; M106; M63, the Sunflower galaxy and M94 as well as big papa bears galaxies M81/M82.

"M8: The Lagoon Nebula in Sagittarius"

Last Saturday was a rushed job as I only got there at 1.30am and imaged all the way till 4.30am, with some visual breaks in between to look at the glorious summer milky way. Can never get enough of M8, the Lagoon Nebula; M20, The Trifid Nebula;, M17, the Swan Nebula;, M16, The Eagle Nebula. Overall a very happy camper. The aim of my next trip therefore will be to re-image summers best and brightest......M20, M17, M16, M57 and M27.......as well as some of the Virgo group of galaxies.....

"M4 Globular (top) and NGC6302: The Bug Nebula (bottom) in Scorpius"